Monday, May 2, 2011

How to make money in a volatile market


“Should I be investing at these levels? Is there any upside left?
“At these levels, the market seems to be poised for a steep correction.”
“Taking equity exposure at these levels would be foolish. Think it is better to stay in cash.”

If you have faced the above dilemma, then you are not alone—almost every investor is facing such dilemma. As the sensex fluctuates around 18000, investors are ecstatic on one hand and petrified on the other.

Investors usually ask us about the probable sensex levels achievable within say next year or so rather than trying to know the rationale behind our recommendation. More often than not, they feel investing in liquid fund is a better option for the moment and then wait for that “inevitable” correction.

Sounds believable, but sometimes the inevitable does not happen. Investors do not realize that more wealth is destroyed in waiting for the correction, then in the correction itself! We have been hearing of the impending correction ever since the sensex crossed 6k levels—and we’ve already reached 18k levels. Though we are not in any way suggesting that the sensex will keep on rising. However, what we do know is that the market is volatile and unpredictable. Else how can you explain the sensex movement from 12500 levels to 8900 and bounce back to 14000 levels all within a matter of few months.

So is there a way to use this volatility to our advantage??

Let us make a model—an extremely conservative and pessimistic one. We have assumed that the sensex goes up by just 8% over 2 year time frame.

The following table is constructed on the premise that the investment time frame is 2 years. Starting on 1/1/2007 at a sensex level of 13942; column A depicts movement of Sensex over 2 years at quarterly intervals. At the end of January 2009, assuming the sensex at 15063, the absolute return works out to be just 8% or 3.94% annualized.

Sensex
Date
Action
Units
NAV
Amount
13942
01/01/2007
Purchase
66.67
150.00
10000
10000
01/04/2007
Purchase
92.95
107.58
10000
12000
01/07/2007
Purchase
77.46
129.10
10000
10600
01/10/2007
Purchase
87.69
114.04
10000
11500
01/01/2008
Purchase
80.82
123.72
10000
10500
01/04/2008
Purchase
88.52
112.96
10000
11500
01/07/2008
Purchase
80.82
123.72
10000
12000
01/10/2008
Purchase
77.46
129.10
10000
15063
01/01/2009
Sale
652.38
162.06
105725
(Source: - moneycontrol.com)

Our MF scheme above exactly mimics the Sensex. The investor invests Rs. 10,000/- every quarter starting 1/1/2007 for 2 years, at the end of which he liquidates his holding. The CAGR of the investor works out to 23.41% against 8% returned by the sensex.

Conclusion
It proves:-

  1. It does not matter whether the market is heated/overheated or not.
  2. It does not matter whether or not it will post double digit return or not.
  3. It does not matter whether there will be a correction or not post your investment.
  4. It is possible to make money as long as the market is volatile and you invest at regular interval.

Sporadic or ad hoc investments are not going to be much helpful. It is regular investment alone that is going to get you another earning member in your family.

You need to do very few things right and avoid making big mistakes. The few right things that you need to do are:-

  • Index level should not guide your investment decision. Rather your goals should be the guiding factor in planning your investments.
  • Choose a diversified equity mutual fund with a good track record. You may if you want choose a core and satellite method in constructing your investment portfolio. Core portfolio may consist of plain vanilla diversified mutual fund while sectoral and theme-based Mutual funds can form the sectoral funds.
  • Invest for long term and invest regularly. 

Saturday, April 30, 2011

MYTHS OF SIP (SYSTEMATIC INVESTMENT PLAN)


SIP is an investment process which allows you to invest a fixed sum every month very much like a recurring fixed deposit with bank.

SIP is an automatic mode of investment which removes the ills of market timing from investments. Investors usually desist buying mutual fund when the markets are down and rather buy when markets are high, in other words retails investors buy high and sell low—just the opposite of what they should be doing.

We have realized that the retail investor has gradually built some mis-conceptions about equity investments via the SIP mode.

Myth 1:- Equity investment is all about SIP

Investors have started to believe or rather they have been made to believe that equity investment should always be done in SIP mode. We believe that if the investor is mature enough to understand the nuances of equity investing and is willing to stay invested for 10 years or so then lump sum investing may be made rather than SIP mode. SIP mode can be beneficial if say the investment horizon is about 5 years or thereabout.

Myth 2:- SIP works in direct equity

We have come across many articles which advocate buying shares of a certain value every month saying and terming it as SIP. Sadly enough this is not SIP.
Take Himachal futuristic Co. Ltd. (HFCL). The script had moved from about Rs. 20 to Rs.2500/- in a matter of a year and back to Rs. 20 levels in following year. Or for that matter take the case of Silverline Technologies which moved from Rs. 30 to Rs. 1300 to Rs.7/-. The moot point is whether you would have had the strength to continue buying through this period. Imagine starting purchases at Rs. 1300/-. You would be cursing stock market today (nobody likes to believe that they have made a mistake). SIP or concept of rupee cost averaging works with a portfolio and not a single stock.

Myth 3:- SIP works For Anybody But Me.

SIP works well in a well diversified equity fund and that too over long term. It may not work well only for people who either have a short term horizon or have not chosen a fund with good track record.
  
Myth 4:- Markets are at all time high and so not a good time to start an SIP.

We do not know whether 3000 is the right index level or 18000 is the right index level to start an SIP. However, what we do know is that SIP works. SIP returns vis-a-vis lump sum returns of select funds between the period December 2007 and March 2011 have been stated here below:-


Scheme
Period
SIP return (CAGR)
Lump Sum return (CAGR)
DSP BR Equity Fund
1st. December 2007—1st.March 2011
20.69%
6.25%
HDFC Equity Fund
1st. December 2007—1st.March 2011
28.45
10.01
Reliance Growth Fund
1st. December 2007—1st.March 2011
17.71
2.79
IDFC Premier Equity Fund
1st. December 2007—1st.March 2011
24.30
8.99
Franklin Prima Plus
1st. December 2007—1st.March 2011
19.19
3.80


So, it is time we break the myths about investing in general and SIP in particular. Let SIP be the second earning member of your family.

Happy SIPing!!

Thursday, April 14, 2011

Difficult Times for EPFO account holder


Can you possibly imagine how would an EPFO investor be feeling today?

His hard earned money being parked with and managed by an organization which

  • Still has archaic accounting system
  • Poor Management of funds  
  • Allows withdrawals in contraventions of law.
  • In all likelihood, the EPFO is running a deficit!
 According to an article in The Economic Times of 8th. April, 2011, Income Tax department has slapped a demand notice on EPFO to the tune of whopping Rs. 7,000 crores. The said demand has been made due to the inability of the EPFO to prevent pre-mature withdrawals which are not allowed under the Indian Income Tax Act, 1956. The liability could have been more had the EPFO maintained proper and updated records. Present system of accounting and recording transactions, does not allow EPFO to track pre-mature withdrawals.

Pre-mature withdrawals—of retirement funds—is allowed—without any taxes-- under Indian Income Tax Act, only under the following situations:-

  • The employee should have been working or had worked for 5 years continuously for the same organization.
  • Had the service been terminated before 5 years, then it must have been for reasons beyond the employee’s control.
  • The accumulated balance standing to the credit of the employee should be transferred to another RPF account only.

Hence, there is no provision for pre-mature withdrawals of EPFO money—tax free unless one of the above conditions arises.

Employees are able to withdraw their PF balances, only because EPFO has not upgraded/modedrnised its accounting system.

The only solution to plug tax leakages lies with EPFO—aggressive fundamental reforms are needed to change the way a corpus of Rs. 170000 odd crores is managed by EPFO. Record keeping has to be improved—and so should the returns being generated by it.

EPFO presently has no system to track workers (or account holders) who have switched jobs. The archaic records do not offer seamless portability. These handicaps negate the very purpose of EPFO—provide & manage retirement money!! In absence of portability, the worker switching jobs is most likely to withdraw his PF dues rather than have it transferred to the new employer.

The only solution to EPFO woes is to offer workers an option to move to NPS (New Pension Scheme) which not only offers seamless portability with restriction on withdrawals, but also has institutional framework to generate superior returns-an obligation--of both the government and EPFO trustees—which is more often overlooked for short term benefits—viz; 9.5% interest only for 1 year (which in all likelihood will be taxed by government)

Friday, February 25, 2011

Do you want to make money or Create wealth!!!


Every fall in stock market gives an opportunity to introspect to find answer to the eternal question:- Why do I invest? Is it to make money or is it to create wealth???
But one may ask --isn't making money same as creating wealth?? No, there's a fine line separating the two.
Making money is just about bank balance while wealth creation is more about meeting goals of your life. Making money may not always lead to wealth creation, but the vice-versa always holds.
To know what kind of investment strategy do you adopt, analyze your strategy in context of the under noted broad points.
Do you take investment/divestment decisions based on market sentiments for the immediate/medium term outlook??
Stock prices are a function of company profitability which in turn depends on the economy in general. Businesses take fairly long time to become profitable. Infosys and Marutis of the world were not made in a day. So you need conviction—and a lot of it—to invest in shares and reap rewards. At times it pays to ignore the noise emanating from the business channels and pink papers.
Do you have the urge to leverage??
A stock market investor is always tempted to make some quick money in F&O since he has always heard his broker talk about big money waiting to be taken home by trading in the F&O. F&O trades may also result in a big loss is apparent only in hind sight. It has the potential of being one of the biggest wealth destroyer.
Does the index level guide your investment/divestment decision?
During the course of our dealings with our investors, we are usually asked whether this is the right time to buy or sell? Honestly speaking, we do not have and never have had an answer to such question! Imagine an investor who had sold off his holdings in Reliance diversified power sector fund at the NAV of Rs.9/- reached within a year of the scheme opening for ongoing subscription, since the outlook to the fund and/or sector was not very encouraging. The fund thereafter has grown investors wealth eight fold over last 6 years.
Do your emotions play any role in devising buy/sell decisions?
Do you feel sad having to see the market gallop away without your participating in it? Do you feel that the whole world except yourself has become rich? Do you thereafter enter the market guided by your feeling left out and trying to make up with the lost time(and profit).
We seldom realize that it is not our thinking that makes big money, but it is sitting. Even the legendary Warren Buffet has said that he would not be worried if the stock market were to open a decade after he bought shares. Facts like these tell us that trading will not help us create wealth.
Do you believe that trading in stocks will help you in building your portfolio?
Investors usually believe or better still they have been conditioned to believe that by regularly buying and selling shares/MFs, you can make money! The moot question is for whom? If you can make money by trading in shares/MFs, than there are equal chances that you may lose some or all also. Can you afford to lose sight of your goals or face the prospect of not being able to meet one or more of them?
If the answer to your analysis as above is positive, then it is time to change your investment strategy.
Wealth creation is akin to hand holding. We invest in companies or Mutual Fund schemes with a clear focus on our goals and our resolve to meet them. Equity as an asset class will deliver inflation adjusted returns but over long term. This “long term” has to be calibrated to your goals. According to an interesting study done by Fidelity, it was shown that over the last 16 odd years, there have been almost equal number of good bad quarters as far as equity returns are concerned. So theoretically, market (sensex)should be still trading close to 3000 levels. But it is trading at 18000 levels.

Friday, February 4, 2011

Why investors must look beyond returns

Investments today come with a shelf life. Rarely do we come across an investor who has held onto his/her investors over very long time. 
Investors tend to forget or overlook the fact that investment is not an end in itself but rather a process to meet your goals. Till a few months before, investors were willing to invest in the equity market since it was moving up. The flow of money turned off or even worse it reversed-- when the market took a beating. In other words investors bought high and sold low--doing exactly the opposite.

Returns or better still maximum returns is the mantra of the day. Any investment yielding less then acceptable return is jettisoned and fresh investment is made in share or mutual fund showing highest return. The fact that it is historical returns that is being displayed rarely comes to the investors mind. We at AIMS always advise our investors to look beyond returns and daily/monthly market movements--rather look at goals for the fulfillment of which the said investment was made in  the first place We re-produce an article "why investors must look beyond returns" here below:-


"Ask an investor, which investment avenue he wants to invest in and there’s more than a fair chance that he will say – the best performing one i.e. one that can deliver the highest returns. Sounds reasonable, doesn’t it? Why would an investor like to settle for anything less than the best, right? The trouble with such an approach is that it oversimplifies the investment process. As a result, emphasis is laid only on the returns aspect; vital factors like risk and suitability are ignored.
Far too often, investors and advisors alike are guilty of falling prey to the allure of high returns. The rationale being, investing is all about clocking the highest return, hence any avenue that can deliver on this front gets the thumbs up. Don’t get us wrong. We are not suggesting that returns aren’t important or that there is necessarily something wrong with an avenue simply because it can deliver a better showing on the returns front vis-à-vis other avenues. However, selecting an investment avenue based solely on its performance is certainly a flawed approach.
In the first place, such an approach erroneously assumes that the investment avenue (say a mutual fund for instance) is an end, rather than a means to achieve an end. While investing, the end should be a tangible goal like providing for one’s retirement, buying a car or simply wealth accumulation, expressed in monetary terms. And once the target sum has been established, appropriate avenues to achieve that end should be chosen. Conversely, if the investment process begins with the selection of the investment avenue, the investor ends up investing in an aimless manner and may never achieve his goals.
Second, by investing in an avenue based solely on returns, the investor runs the risk of getting invested in an avenue that might be unsuitable for him in terms of the risk involved. For instance in the equity funds segment, by and large one would expect a diversified equity fund (which invests its entire corpus in equities) to outperform a balanced fund (which invests around 65%-75% of its corpus in equities and the balance in debt instruments) in times when equity markets are rising. But from an investor’s perspective, the key lies in determining what’s right for him.
For example, assume that a balanced fund can deliver a 12% CAGR over a 5-Yr period; conversely, a diversified equity fund is equipped to deliver a 15% CAGR over the same time

frame. Say an investor wishes to accumulate Rs 500,000 for a holiday 5 years down the line. Now the investor has to choose between investing in a balanced fund or in a diversified equity fund. Should the investor decide to build a corpus using a balanced fund, he will have to invest around Rs 6,223 per month or Rs 78,705 pa. Conversely, opting for an equity fund will necessitate a lower investment i.e. Rs 5,792 per month or Rs 74,158 pa.
Most investors might instinctively opt for the equity fund option on account of the higher return (i.e. a lower investment amount). However, while making the choice, the risk factor has been ignored. On account of the debt holdings in the portfolio, the balanced fund is invested across asset classes i.e. equity and debt. Over the 5-Yr investment horizon, should equity markets witness a rough patch, the balanced fund will be better equipped to protect the investor’s corpus. In effect, the trade-off for the higher investment amount is the proposition of delivering during a downturn in markets. Before making a choice, the investor should first evaluate his risk appetite and then choose between the balanced fund and the equity fund.
Another reason investors opt for the best performing avenues is excitement. Yes, you read that right. There is a section of investors, which believes that the investment activity should be exciting; hence selecting investment avenues offering the highest returns is justified. For the record, investing has nothing to do with excitement; on the contrary, investing is serious business and is all about achieving one’s predetermined financial goals. Seeking excitement from the investment activity amounts to trivializing it.
In conclusion, investors would do well to look beyond just returns while making an investment decision. Sure, returns are important, but certainly not a parameter to be considered in isolation. The key lies in looking at the investment activity in totality and then making a decision. If not, investors run the risk of missing the wood for the trees.

Sunday, January 30, 2011

What not to do in 2011


It is almost a truism that most people need basic financial literacy and it’s generally assumed that this literacy must take the form of knowing what to do with money. However, the truth could be exactly the opposite. It would be far more useful for people to instead learn what not to do with their money and this education is not available anywhere.
We try to list here below some don’t dos for you for 2011. The idea is enable you to do few right things and prevent you from making big mistakes. Jaago investor jaago……

Thou shalt not blindly buy high return products

One thing that frauds like the one at Citi bank may have taught us is that there cannot be any investments without “risks”. Promise of high return without commensurate higher degree of risks is just not possible. Structured products are good only if you invest after understanding it. Else avoiding them will not prove to be disastrous to your hard earned money! Follow KIS----keep it simple

Thou shalt not leverage

There can be products that although pass the test of legality, are best to avoid. Consider an investor who prefers to invest in blue chip stocks and prefers to hold them for long term. Such an investor will invariably be brain washed by his friendly broker to leverage his holdings by investing in derivatives. We have come across brokers who try to impress upon their clients that holding on to blue chip stocks for long term is a foolish thing to do, since the client misses out on the massive returns that can be his. The client will be encouraged to trade in derivatives and take home the high returns that derivative segment supposedly offers. The client becomes aware of the risk part of the derivative segment but only after it is too late—the client invariably loses not only his blue chip holdings but also his faith in the market and its intermediaries. The client is gone for good.

Thou shalt buy term insurance

It has been proved that Indians are under-insured. We do not have enough cover. Term insurance is hardly ever recommended by your “family insurance agent”. This is because an endowment or ULIP will fetch them far more commission that a term insurance policy. That term insurance is the basic financial product that everyone should buy in big numbers is understood but rarely followed. One of the basic principles of financial planning is that your family’s future should first be secured by way of adequate insurance coverage—term insurance in other words.

For the investor, not doing the wrong things should actually be learnt before doing the right things. Unfortunately, this is something that they’re likely to learn the hard way

Tuesday, January 11, 2011

Fear, Greed and Panic

Over the last few days, the standard investing punditry that is available on business TV and newspapers has turned fiercely negative. The consensus view is that we're doomed. The line-up of problems that are going to ruin us all is impressive indeed. Not only is the inflation rate rising, but so are inflationary expectations and that's supposed to be worse. There is a genuine fear in the air that growth is slowing down.

Among people who to invest in equities and equity-based mutual funds, the natural question to ask is what they should do now. In response, the best thing I can think of is to quote the great investor Warren Buffett. Buffett is fond of saying that one should be fearful when others are greedy and greedy when others are fearful. It sound like such an overly cute thing to say that you may feel that it's good only for printing on inspirational posters but actually, like everything else that Buffett says, it's deeper than it looks.
Clearly, others are fearful now. Does that mean that it's time to be greedy? It probably is. In one of his interview he had said something very interesting in response to a question about what investors should do now that stocks have started declining. Here's what he said. “The answer is you don't want investors to think that what they read today is important in terms of their investment strategy. Their investment strategy should factor in that (a) if you knew what was going to happen in the economy, you still wouldn't necessarily know what was going to happen in the stock market. And (b) they can't pick stocks that are better than average. Stocks are a good thing to own over time. There are only two things you can do wrong: You can buy the wrong ones, and you can buy or sell them at the wrong time. And the truth is you never need to sell them, basically. But they

could buy a cross section of American industry, and if a cross section of American industry doesn't work, certainly trying to pick the little beauties here and there isn't going to work either. Then they just have to worry about getting greedy. I always say you should get greedy when others are fearful and fearful when others are greedy. But that's too much to expect. At a minimum, you shouldn't get greedy when others get greedy and fearful when others get fearful”.
Just change 'American' to 'Indian' in these words and then read them carefully. It's so far removed from what most people think investing is all about that it takes time to figure out what this amazingly successful old man is saying. What he is saying that long-term success of investing is based not on the fact that the investor will be able pick the 'little beauties' but on the fact that country's economy is going to grow. What is happening now, (the short-term news flow) is not important because regardless of what you hear, what is happening in the country and the economy in the short-term may not be a good indicator of what is going to happen in the stock markets in the short-term. There are too many factors, too much noise, that affect the markets for the average investor to figure out.
Another factor that can contribute to increase in your wealth is your ability to macro manage your investments and not micro managing our investments. We are so obsessed to micro manage our investments that more often than not we tend to ignore the bigger picture. The bigger picture is that our economy is growing. There may be differences about the growth rate, but there’s no denying the fact that we are growing! Even at say 6% p.a., we are one of the fastest growing economies in the world. This growth is sooner rather than later, going to be reflected in the corporate earnings and hence in their stock prices, as stock price is a slave of earnings. Our obsession to time our investment with movement of Sensex or Nifty is faulty also on the ground that they do not reflect the total picture. 

However, in the long-term all the noise gets cancelled out and you are left with one single question. Is the country's economy going to grow? If you think the answer is yes, then that's a good reason to go ahead and own a broad cross-section of stocks. The bonus is that because it is a time when others are fearful, a lot of investments are 
cheaper than they were just a short while back.

Let me prove it with facts. To do it we will have to go back in time.

Past-looking
I turn to history and begin with the growth rate in the Indian economy as defined by the growth rate in India’s GDP.
The data indicates that - over the 28 year period from 1980 to 2007 - the rate of growth in real GDP was 6.2% per annum. The "real" means after inflation - after the fake increase in wealth caused by an increase in prices.
I add back inflation - which averaged about 7% for the past 28 years. This allows me to get a sense of how the Indian economy grew at "nominal" prices. Combining the two, I broadly see that the Indian economy grew by more than 13% every year for the past 28 years. Not bad, considering that we had a closed economy all this while, with under performing public sector.

And the BSE-30 Index increased by 18% every year since 1980.

That is the past.

This growth has come inspite of the famines, wars, assassinations, bankruptcy of our economy et all. Is there anything to suggest that the next 30 years will be different from the last 30 years?
It took us nearly 60 years to become $1 trillion economy---it’s going to take only 5-6 years to double it going forward at the present growth rate. Are we going to let this milestone pass just because Sensex/Nifty gyrating to temporary news flows—and in the process ignoring the inherent strengths in the economy??